In Paris, around the turn of the last century, Pierre Janet took on a young woman he called Irène. Her mother was dying in a small workman’s room, and Irène nursed her through the last stretch, staying awake for nights at a time and leaving the bedside to go to work so there would be money. When the death came she tried to bring her mother round, and the body slid from the bed to the floor. After the funeral Irène began to walk in her sleep. In the trances she replayed the room, the dialogue and the postures, and in one she staged her own death under a train. Then she would come back to ordinary waking life and go to work. Janet filed the case under hysteria.
More than sixty years later Kazimierz Dąbrowski read Janet’s notes and called her healthy. He meant that she was doing the one thing available to a person whose attachment had been cut off with nowhere else for it to go. Without the dissociation, he wrote, her feeling for her mother could have ended in suicide or psychosis. The sleepwalking was not the illness. It was a structure refusing to close back over the wound.
I have spent years with that theory. My mother died on 17 October.
What Dąbrowski meant by positive
The word does most of the damage in the popular version. Dąbrowski did not use positive to mean good, and he did not mean redemptive. Disintegration was negative, in his 1964 definition, when it had no developmental effect or when it caused involution, a collapse backward. It was positive when the loosened structure did not reassemble as it had been. In the 1970 book he put the common case bluntly: most people, after a short period of disintegration, usually in adolescence, end in a reintegration at the former level. The personality shakes, then settles into the same shape. Two years later he wrote that a developmental solution to a crisis means not a reintegration but an integration at a higher level of functioning. A crisis that returns you to yourself has, by his lights, done nothing.
He allowed that experiences of shock, stress and trauma, in his words, may accelerate development. He did not say they do.
So the question his vocabulary puts to a bereaved person is whether the arrangement that held before the death will hold after it. The research on that question has an answer.
What happens to most people
In 2002 George Bonanno and colleagues published data on 205 older adults in the United States who had been interviewed several years before their spouse died and again at six and eighteen months afterward. Because the measurements began before the loss, the researchers could see what each person had been like going in. Five patterns appeared. The one the textbooks had taught, a deep decline followed by slow recovery, was relatively infrequent. The commonest pattern was resilience: low distress throughout, a person who was more or less the same before and after.
That finding has held. A 2026 systematic review of twelve longitudinal trajectory studies put the average at 55 per cent resilient, 33 per cent recovering and about 10 per cent in chronic grief. An Australian postal survey of 678 people bereaved six to 24 months earlier, run by Samar Aoun and Lauren Breen at Curtin University, came out at 58, 35 and 6. Adult children losing a parent sit at the gentler end of these distributions. When Thomas Leopold and Clemens Lechner followed 2,760 adults in the German Socio-Economic Panel through a parent’s death, with up to eleven yearly measurements each, life satisfaction fell and then returned, with two exceptions: daughters who lost their mothers fell furthest, and people bereaved young, off time, had not fully adapted several years on.
For an adult whose parent has died in the ordinary order of things, the data are not ambiguous. The dip is real and it closes. Margaret Stroebe, Henk Schut and Kathrin Boerner have argued that the five stages should be discarded altogether, on the grounds that the evidence for them was never there and that the expectation of passing through them harms the people who don’t. What the trajectory studies add is that most bereaved people do not pass through anything. They absorb the loss into a structure that was already strong enough to take it.
Put that next to Dąbrowski. The majority outcome, the one the clinicians call resilience and are right to be relieved by, is what he called reintegration at the former level. The structure held. In his terms, nothing happened.
Growth is mostly a story told afterwards
The culture has an answer ready for the minority the structure does not hold, which is that their suffering will make them more. The research on that answer has not reached the people who repeat it.
In 2009 Patricia Frazier and colleagues measured 122 students on the usual growth domains two months apart, then compared the measured change in the ones who had been through a traumatic event in between with what those students reported on the standard Posttraumatic Growth Inventory. The reported growth was unrelated to the measured change. Reported growth went with rising distress, and real change went with falling distress, which suggests they are different things wearing the same name. Adriel Boals reviewed the field in 2023 and concluded that illusory growth is common and measurable growth is rare. When Amaris Grant, Michael Furr and Eranda Jayawickreme asked 21 people this year to think aloud while answering the inventory, none of them completed, for every item, the before-and-after comparison the instrument assumes. They reached instead for continuity in their own story, and for what the researchers called cultural scripts favouring positive transformation. They reported growth where their own account showed none.
That is the trap Dąbrowski’s theory gets pulled into, and it is not his trap. Irène did not grow. She acted out her mother’s death in her sleep for months. What he saw in her was a refusal, by some part of her she could not reach while awake, to let the self that had sat at the bedside be folded back into the one that went to work. He called that refusal the beginning of a personality. He also wrote down what it could cost her, and recommended a warm environment and a direction for her abilities.
Which structure is holding
There is a dynamism in his list he called subject-object in oneself: the capacity to look at your own mental life as if from outside. He did not define it cleanly in the 1970 book. In one case study there he says it shows in a patient’s careful observation of his own changing states. I read it, and this is my reading rather than his, as the beginning of doing for yourself what the first person who ever looked at you used to do. Irène kept staging the scene with a spectator in it. Someone had to watch.
A mother is, for most people, the original outside position. She saw you before you could see yourself, and some part of the arrangement you call yourself was built facing her. When she dies the arrangement does not necessarily fall. The data say it usually does not. But the thing it was built facing is gone, and Dąbrowski’s question is whether it keeps standing because it is sound or because nothing has yet asked it to move.
What I notice in myself is reorganising. In adult life whole days went by with no word between us, and nothing in me registered it. Now the days go by and I want to talk to her, which is the shape of the gap and not the gap itself. My wife, who has lost both her parents, said it better than I can: you are trying to work out who you are as a person without that person in your life.
The research resolves one thing. Most people who lose a parent in adulthood return to roughly where they were, and the stories about stages and about growth are both, on the evidence, stories. What it does not resolve is whether returning is the good outcome. Dąbrowski said it was the one where nothing happened. The clinicians say it is the one to hope for. They are describing the same person from the outside, and neither has a word for the inside of the weeks where you do not yet know which structure you are.
If this is the kind of thinking that doesn't leave when the tab closes.
Subscribe